Love at First Bite Reviews...

5.00 ★ (10)
Verified

Pick Your Vibe

**The Right Box for the Moment**

Brownies | Cookie Pies | Tortes


Not every great dessert comes in a 6-ounce cookie. Explore our collection of flourless chocolate cookies, deep-dish cookie pies, cheesecake mini, brownies, and other indulgent creations that color outside the lines. 

Gluten-friendly (Flourless)

We are not a gluten-free certified kitchen, but we do have a few items that are made without any flour whatsoever and are just as delicious! These sell out fast.

Pickup & Nationwide Shipping

Preorders


Preorder online Sunday through Thursday at 8:00 p.m. and select Local Pickup at checkout.

In-Store Pickup


Visit us at our shared commercial kitchen inside The Unforgettable Bakery, located at 238 Eisenhower Drive, Savannah, GA.

Beginning July 19, we'll be open for pickup and walk-in purchases on the 1st and 3rd Sundays of each month from 11:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m.

We'll have a small assortment of fresh gourmet cookies available while supplies last, but we always recommend preordering to guarantee your favorite flavors.

Tybee Pickup


Prefer Tybee Island? We're happy to deliver prepaid orders to Sandcat Coffee. Simply select Local Pickup at checkout, and we'll email you to arrange a pickup day and time.

Nationwide Shipping

We proudly ship our gourmet cookies and wedding cake sample boxes anywhere in the continental United States.

At this time, items requiring refrigeration—including cheesecakes and cupcakes—are available for local pickup only and are not eligible for shipping.