Your perfect cookie box starts here.
Choose any six handcrafted 6-ounce gourmet cookies from This Month's Cookie Menu. Our selection features a mix of customer favorites and rotating seasonal creations, so there's always something new to discover.
Every cookie is handcrafted in small batches using premium ingredients, individually wrapped for freshness, and baked fresh to order.
Flavors change seasonally—see This Month's Cookie Menu below to make your selections.
Cookie flavor descriptions:
🍪 Cinnamon Caramel Chocolate Chip
Brown butter, ribbons of caramel, warm cinnamon, and mini semisweet chocolate chips create the perfect cozy cookie.
🍁 Maple Pecan
Pure maple and toasted pecans come together in a rich, buttery cookie that's made for coffee lovers.
☕ Moon River Mocha
An espresso-kissed chocolate cookie inspired by Savannah's favorite after-dinner indulgence.
🌊 Tybee Ocean Cookie
A beach-inspired cookies & cream creation with a delightful surprise tucked inside.
🌈 M&M Stuffed with Nutella
A colorful chocolate chip cookie hiding a rich, creamy Nutella center for the ultimate surprise.
🍪 Classic Chocolate Chip
Our signature take on the classic, loaded with both milk and semisweet chocolate chips for the perfect balance of rich, buttery flavor.
🍌 Front Porch Banana Pudding
A Southern favorite inspired by homemade banana pudding, complete with creamy vanilla notes and nostalgic comfort in every bite.
Shipping: Available for nationwide shipping, flat rate through USPS.
Local pickup: 2 options: one of our team members can hand off your order at Sandcat Coffee or pick up at our commercial location (inside the Unforgettable Bakery at 238 Eisenhower Dr., Savannah, GA) every 1st & 3rd Sunday of each month 11am-2pm.
Allergen information, please click here.
